You have no items in your shopping cart.
SHOP OUR PRODUCTS
Aged Yellow Cheddar
You’ll enjoy the midly sharp, flavorful, all-purpose cuts
of this Sharp Cheddar Cheese. A great complement to
a meat or cheese tray for entertaining or for the
holidays. One of our favorites!
$9.99
Cheese Preserves
Cheese Preserves add the perfect delectable touch to your cheese snack. Spread over your favorite cheese variety, or enjoy with a cracker!
Available in three delicious flavors.
Available in three delicious flavors.
$9.79
Ziller
Awarded 1st place at the 2025 United States Championship Cheese Contest and the 2024 World Championship Cheese Contest! 1st place winner at the 2024 Ohio State Fair.
The perfect "in-between" cheese for Swiss & Baby Swiss!
$9.49
1 lb. Wedge Original Baby Swiss
The Cheese that Made us Famous! Our Original Baby Swiss is delightfully mild and creamy, and loved by all.
Awarded 1st place at the 2023 United States Championship!
2019 U.S. GRAND CHAMPION & #1 CHEESE IN AMERICA!
Pairs Well With: Weiss Beer, Sparkling wines, Pinot noir, White Zinfandel, Riesling Nuts, dried fruit, peaches, melon
Awarded 1st place at the 2023 United States Championship!
2019 U.S. GRAND CHAMPION & #1 CHEESE IN AMERICA!
Pairs Well With: Weiss Beer, Sparkling wines, Pinot noir, White Zinfandel, Riesling Nuts, dried fruit, peaches, melon
$9.49
Amish Butter Cheese
You'll love the mild, rich, & buttery flavor of this Guggisberg signature cheese. It melts well and is great for cooking!
$9.49